Discover Manhattan Pizzeria, a cozy pizza restaurant in Indianapolis offering casual dining with popular options like Pepperoni Pizza, Sicilian with Cheese, and Baked Ziti Pasta. Wheelchair accessible with dine-in, takeout, and delivery service.
6225 W 56th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254, United States
Six quick facts to help you decide before you visit.
4.7 stars based on 550 reviews
$10 to $20 per person
6225 W 56th St, Indianapolis, IN 46254
Open daily from 10:30 AM; closes at 8 PM weekdays and Sundays, 9 PM Fridays and Saturdays
Delivery, dine-in, takeout, and onsite services available
Wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, seating, and restrooms
Free parking lot and street parking available
Manhattan Pizzeria offers a classic New York-style pizza experience in a casual and cozy setting along Indianapolis’ West 56th Street. Known for its crisp, thin crusts with the signature fold and subtle char, this spot serves authentic, comfort pizza that has earned a loyal following among locals and visitors alike. Its menu features a variety of slices, pies, and small plates, including vegetarian options and the notable Baked Ziti Pasta.
With an approachable price range of $10 to $20, quick service, and an inviting atmosphere that suits solo diners, families, and groups, Manhattan Pizzeria is a reliable choice for lunch or dinner. Amenities like free parking and onsite restrooms complement its straightforward counter-service model, while the friendly staff and efficient preparation ensure a satisfying visit, whether dining in or taking out.
While the standout quality is the fresh, authentic pizza made with care and speed, occasional mixed experiences with sides and extras suggest sticking to the pizza as the safest and most rewarding option.
Whether grabbing a quick slice or settling in for a relaxed meal, Manhattan Pizzeria’s offerings and atmosphere accommodate a variety of everyday dining occasions.
Quick, flavorful pizza options at affordable prices make this a perfect spot for grabbing a satisfying lunch, whether solo or with colleagues, within a short visit.
The casual and quiet atmosphere pairs well with groups and families seeking a comfortable, no-fuss meal served with speedy counter service and free parking.
Enjoy a relaxed evening with classic New York-style pizza and small plates in a cozy setting, ideal for low-key dinners without table service.
Convenient delivery and takeout options make it easy to enjoy Manhattan Pizzeria’s signature pies at home without compromising on quality or taste.
Address, contact, and weekly opening times at a glance.
Opening hours may vary. Suggest an update if this information has changed.
Quick answers about menu, location, dining options, and updates.
Keep exploring Indiana with brands that match this craving.
View dishes, prices, popular picks, and menu categories for Manhattan Pizzeria.
